- Michelin GuideUnion Street InnNantucket9.7
- Valleys & ViewsNantucket10.0
- Michelin GuideWhaling MuseumNantucket
- 45A Pleasant StNantucket10.0
- Ireland TimeNantucket9.5
- 29 India HouseNantucket9.5
- Airy Nantucket Escape in Historic Downtown!Nantucket
- The 1957 HouseNantucket7.5
- Michelin Guide21 BroadNantucket8.8
- 52 UnionNantucket
- Michelin GuideMain StreetNantucket
- Love Sand, Madaket on the BeachNantucket9.5
- The Centerboard NantucketNantucket8.8
- Michelin GuideNantucket
- Michelin GuideHawden HouseNantucket
- 45B Pleasant StNantucket10.0
- Michelin GuideThe Wauwinet Nantucket9.3Wauwinet
- End of results -